Surviving Panic While Scuba Diving

by Rick Spencer
(Remington, VA USA)

Hello, my name is Rick. I learned to dive in the late 1980’s as part of a community college program. I have been asked to share two “war stories” about panic; one of the most dangerous situations a diver can experience.

The first incident of panic occurred during my open water certification. At the time, I lived near a quarry that had been turned into a training site by one of the dive stores in my area. The quarry had been set up with platforms so that groups could go through various exercises at 33’.

On this particular dive, I was the only student. The instructor went over the plan and the tasks we were going to accomplish. The last item would be a buddy breathing exercise.

Everything was going to plan when the instructor signaled it was time to buddy breath. Alternate Air Source devices had just started becoming common place, but running through the sharing of a single second stage was still good practice.

We moved into position, grabbing hold of each other’s BCD. I took a breath and started to exhale and passed my regulator to the instructor. As soon as it was out of my mouth I knew I was exhaling too fast. I thought of reaching for the alternate but thought it would be a bad idea.

Seconds later, the panic set it and I kicked off the platform for the surface. The instructor grabbed my weight belt, forced me back to the platform and shoved the regulator back into my mouth.

The second panic instance took place at the same quarry a few years later during a night dive for Advanced Open Water. This time I was with a group and had a buddy. The instructor ran through the plan. The quarry has a vertical wall; the plan was we would surface swim to the wall and as a group head to the bottom then swim off to the platform. We tied green chemical sticks to our tanks, did a check and got wet.

The group met at the spot and we started down. My buddy and I arrived on the bottom together and looked in the direction of the platform for the other divers…we could not see the group, the green chem. lights, or flashlights.

We signaled each other that we didn’t know which way to go…instead of getting lost in the dark we mutually signaled to head up. I began the process of swimming to the surface when my fin kicked off of one of the anchoring cables running from the platform to the wall and in my mind and confusion the thought came to me that I wasn’t going up. I started to kick faster and had the sensation that I wasn’t getting enough air and that I should spit out my regulator.

One of the things that the classroom sessions had covered was this very impulse and the words came back to me, “You’ll want to spit it out and breath…and you will not survive. Fight the impulse, it will pass quickly.” I finally made it to the surface and inflated my BCD until the over-inflate valves popped. We related our experience to the group when everyone was back on the beach.

Lessons learned:

Plan the Dive, then Dive the Plan

In both situations, the plan was reviewed and followed. After a few decades of retrospect, the only thing I would have changed is to add signals that indicate a problem as well as landmarks and compass bearings.

Know your equipment and use it

Alternate Air Sources are pretty standard in today’s diving. Learning the Buddy Breathing process should still be a part of your buddy system, but as a last resort. Don’t be afraid to use the device.

Know your partner

There are specific signs of panic that can be recognized. The biggest sign is that a person’s eyes open very wide. Thankfully, my instructor saw my panic and stopped my accent. Two weeks later, same quarry, same buddy breathing exercise, a teenaged girl was not so lucky and died of Lung Expansion.

My goal in sharing these stories is to help others learn from my experiences. At some point everyone faces a degree of panic. Planning, preparation and communication will help you through the problem. Listen to the sages…learn the emergency procedures, know your equipment and your capabilities. Be prepared for the unexpected and know what to do ahead of time.

Comments for Surviving Panic While Scuba Diving

Average Rating starstarstarstarstar

Click here to add your own comments

Panic, Not on my bucket list
by: Legendary Lee

Thanks for sharing your stories. Glad you made it out safely. I remember in the 60's and diving in Fiji, during a military R&R. Had a complication with my regulator in about 40 feet. I remember all to clearly the sense of panic and trying to supress it. I was had the presence of mind to somehow signal my dive partner who saw my panic. I pointed to my regulator and we buddy breathed until we surfaced.
And at age 69, I am starting lessons again? But it makes knee & hip pain go

Out of air
by: Kelly

I was on the bottom thought I had plenty of air 400lbs at 30 ft started back up and ran out , not just out it stopped , the natural reaction was to draw in more air so unconsciously I exhaled with nothing left in tank talk about panic mode. Needless to say never again. Kelly

Panic while diving
by: Anonymous

I enjoyed the story. Reminded me of my first certification in 1981. It was after that time I wanted to learn how to spear fishing. During my research I learned that " a diver must logged 50 dives before learning how to spear a fish " . Due to spearing a fish 5-10lbs , a diver will be baffled as to who caught who. Knowing this I made sure that I had logged 50 dives ( when I knew, I was comfortable in the water, during the day or night) before thanking the advance and search and rescue diving. Your dive partner depends on you.

by: Anonymous

Great story Rick. Im glad your safe. I wont be Scuba diving!

Good Lessons
by: Dianne

Thanks so much for sharing your stories Rick. It is greatly appreciated.

Luckily both incidents had good endings but as your story illustrates, panic and scuba diving can be a deadly mix (such a tragic story about that young lady).

Good lessons outlined there. We can all learn from them.

Thanks again.

Click here to add your own comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to Your Scuba Dive Story.

 Want to stay down longer and improve your buoyancy control and other diving skills? Our free report "Increase Your Bottom Time" along with our practical, weekly actionable tips will have you looking like a seasoned diver in no time. So come join us and see improvement on your very next dive!
(Click on the photo to join us now!)

Click here to subscribe

What's New

  1. Happy New Year

    Jan 01, 24 06:00 AM

    Happy New Year everyone! I hope everyone is well and had a fun New Years Eve! May your new year be filled with lots of wonderful dives. All the best to you and yours in 2024! Let the dives begin.

    Read More

  2. Happy Holidays

    Dec 14, 23 05:05 AM

    I hope everyone is enjoying the holiday season! I am always amazed at how fast time flies and another year is just around the corner. I wanted to pop in and say hi to everyone. I am doing some full ti…

    Read More

  3. 3 Common Scuba Diving Mistakes New Divers Make

    Feb 23, 23 02:18 PM

    3 Common Scuba Diving Mistakes
    In this video, I share 3 common scuba diving mistakes beginner divers make. Learn how to correct these for a better - and safer - dive.

    Read More

  4. Scuba Diving Tipping Etiquette: How Much And When To Tip Scuba Crew

    Feb 06, 23 03:34 PM

    scuba diving tipping etiquette
    Not sure of scuba diving tipping etiquette? In this video I share who to tip, when to tip, how much to tip, tipping on liveaboards, tipping an instructor & more

    Read More

  5. Scuba Diving Tips For First Time

    Jan 29, 23 05:41 PM

    scuba diving tips for first time divers
    These scuba diving tips for first time divers will help improve buoyancy control, air consumption, equalization and boat diving. Improve on your very next dive!

    Read More