How do you choose the best snorkel and/or snorkel set for you? After all, there many types and styles of snorkels available.
Whether you are using it while scuba diving or for snorkeling only.
We have written this guide in the hope that it will help make your choice easier. We tell you the main things to consider in a snorkel and which features may or may not be for you.
But to put your mind at ease, one of the first things to understand is that any snorkel will basically get the job done.
The snorkel is (well, let's make that, can be) a simple piece of gear and all will let you breathe while your face is underwater.
However, there are many features available which may get the job done more comfortably and efficiently than the basic rigid "J" snorkel. It all comes down to your preference and how often you will be using the snorkel.
So, with that being said, what do you look for when choosing a snorkel?
Comfort and Fit
The mouthpiece should be comfortable in your mouth and the snorkel should not feel like it is pulling at your mouth (at least not excessively). The more comfortable mouthpieces are typically made of silicon. There is a bite piece which you bite down on to keep the snorkel in your mouth. You should not feel like you are biting down with a ton of force.
Features
There are many features of a snorkel to help make your experience more comfortable and efficient. For instance, a purge valve makes it easier and more efficient to clear a snorkel. Without one you have to tilt your head back, blow forcefully through the tube or take the mouthpiece out of your mouth to clear the snorkel.
Not that this is particularly hard, but a purge valve just makes it easier.
A flexible barrel will also help in getting a more comfortable fit for your snorkel.
The same is said to go for a rotating mouthpiece. I have never tried one of these so I can't speak from personal experience, but it makes sense that it would help the comfort level.
For a detailed discussion on these features, read our page on scuba snorkels. It will also help in choosing the best snorkel for you.
Semi-dry/Dry
You have the choice between an open tube, semi-dry snorkel or dry snorkel.
Which type of these scuba diving snorkels is best for you is personal preference. If you consistently swim in rough water, you will probably want to opt for at least a semi-dry snorkel. That way you won't be gulping large amounts of water.
A dry snorkel has it's advantages, especially if you are prone to diving down alot to check out things underwater (and if you want to keep your eye on something below you). One disadvantage I have read about dry snorkels is that it is sometimes hard to get a good breath (not all the time, but occasionally).
Do you enjoy the Caribbean and/or scuba diving as much as we do? Then come and join the Coco Zone Dive Club newsletter. As a subscriber you'll receive:
Our Free Ecourse: 5 Days to Better Diving and Dive Travel
Our printable Caribbean Scuba Diving Vacation Packing List. We use this everytime we go on a tropical vacation - whether we are scuba diving or not. Use this list so you don't get caught without any of the essentials (ever pay $15 for 4 oz. of sunscreen in a hotel gift shop?). We also include 12 things you need to do before you even leave home.
Information on product recalls and the latest industry and island news. Make sure you aren't diving with a faulty piece of equipment - we'll let you know when we hear about a product recall. Keep up to date on scuba diving and island news. Be an informed traveler.
So come and join us and get the most out of your scuba diving experiences. And don't worry, we will never sell or give away your email address. We hate spam just as much as you do.
Length and Diameter
If the tube of your snorkel is too short, it will constantly be filling with water. If it is too long, it will be harder to get a full breath and harder to exhale all the air or water out of the tube.
The same goes for a larger diameter snorkel. The larger the diameter, the larger the dead space and the harder it is to clear the tube. Conversely, if the diameter is too narrow, it will make it harder to inhale and exhale.
Ideally you want to minimize the dead space you have in a snorkel without the snorkel being too short or too narrow. That way it will be easier to clear the snorkel of any CO2 buildup and any water in the tube.
I can't say that there is an ideal length or diameter for everyone since every body is different and everyone uses a snorkel in their own particular way. I've read some suggestions on the internet regarding length and size but nothing that seemed to come from an expert voice so I don't want to repeat them here (if you know of any, please let me know).
That being said, most modern snorkels today will be appropriate for the average diver/snorkeler. I wouldn't get too hung up on it. Have a talk with your salesperson and/or the manufacturer if you have any doubt about the best snorkel for you.
Bulk
The more bells and whistles you have on a snorkel, the chances are the bulkier it will be. This could cause the snorkel to have more drag, catch on something while you are diving or just plain annoy you. While it may be a great snorkel, it may not be the best snorkel once you hit the water.
Price
A scuba diving snorkel is probably one of the least expensive pieces of scuba gear you will be buying. So price isn't as much a consideration as it is when you are buying a dive computer,scuba BCD or scuba regulator.
You can get a good selection of decent snorkels in the $15-$25 range. The most expensive models are usually the dry snorkels and these are typically priced in the $30-$50 range.
It gets high marks from users and has received many good reviews (over 50 as of this writing in December 2011). Pros of this snorkel are high ratings for comfort, resistance to flooding and its purge valve. All things that will make your snorkeling experience that much more comfortable.
We do have another option for you though (OK, we couldn't just stop at one). If you prefer not to have a dry snorkel, we chose another snorkel that might be a better fit for you. The good news is that it is at a lower price point. Who doesn't want to save money?
It has received good reviews for comfort and design. The purge valve is also noted as a nice feature as well as the flexible tubing on the bottom of the snorkel. This is a tried and true model and many people have been using this snorkel for years. You can't get a better recommendation than that.
It consistently gets high ratings from users. Most are surprised at the quality for the price. Especially when it comes to the fins which get strong reviews.
The vast majority of reviews were positive for the mask - good vision, comfort, no leaks, etc. A few users mentioned that they couldn't get the strap to hold tight enough for their face (a replacement strap would be an easy and inexpensive fix if this is the case; fyi - I use a padded strap for my mask since I find it more comfortable than the plastic ones that come with my masks).
At this price point and given all the postive reviews, it gets our vote for best snorkel set value.
If you are going to do alot of snorkeling and want to upgrade to a higher quality set, this other US Divers set gets our vote as best overall snorkel gear set.
Users give it very high marks for quality and comfort. The fins are shorter so it is a great snorkel set for travel.
Even though the fins are shorter, reviewers state that they are still powerful. The fins also come with a quick release strap which makes them easy to put on and off.
The snorkel is a dry snorkel so you won't be swallowing that sea water.
The mask also gets high marks for comfort and fit. The vast majority of users had no problems with leaks - always a plus for a mask!
This pick for best snorkel set comes with a bag to hold all your gear and as an added bonus they give you some fish food to get your adventure started. So what are you waiting for?
Hopefully we have made your choice of the best snorkel for you a bit easier. If not, feel free to drop us a line and let us know.
For more information, check out our other pages on masks and snorkels: